I love those “Aha!” moments. The kind of moments that only
come because you know the books so well that you've got the seventh novel
running in the back of your brain as you read the first one again.
Not that I want to be aggressively critical of J.K. Rowling.
In fact, I think it's because she makes so few “continuity errors” over the
course of these seven incredibly complex books that I actually feel joy when I
find one. The fact that it's taken me about 20 readings of the novels to spot
this one makes it even more amazing.
Take the following passages from Chapter 6 of The
Philosopher's Stone:
[Harry] pulled the
ticket Hagrid had given him out of his pocket.
“I just take the train
from platform nine and three quarters at eleven o'clock,” he read.
His aunt and uncle
stared.
“Platform what?”
“Nine and three
quarters.”
“Don't talk rubbish,”
said Uncle Vernon, “there's no platform nine and three quarters.”
“It's on my ticket.”
“Barking,” said Uncle
Vernon, “howling mad, the lot of them. You'll see. You just wait.”
And later...
“Well, there you are,
boy. Platform nine – platform ten. Your platform should be somewhere in the
middle, but they don't seem to have built it yet, do they?”
He was quite right, of
course. There was a big plastic number nine over one platform and a big plastic
number ten over the one next to it, and in the middle, nothing at all.
“Have a good term,”
said Uncle Vernon with an even nastier smile. He left without another word.
Harry turned and saw the Dursleys drive away. All three of them were laughing.
Reading those two sections, you would believe that Aunt
Petunia is as incredulous over Harry's claim that there is actually a platform
nine and three quarters at King's Cross Station as Uncle Vernon is. No, Petunia
doesn't actually say anything but she does first “stare” at Harry when he first
introduces the idea of platform nine and three quarters and then joins in the
derisive laughter when the Dursley family drives away, leaving Harry lost and
stranded at King's Cross.
So we are given to believe that Petunia has never heard of
platform nine and three quarters and is as skeptical as her husband regarding
the possibility of its existence.
Now read this passage from Snape's memory montage in Chapter
33 of The Deathly Hallows:
And the scene
reformed. Harry looked around: he was on platform nine and three quarters., and
Snape stood beside him, slightly hunched, next to a thin, sallow faced,
sour-looking woman who greatly resembled him. Snape was staring at a family of
four a short distance away. The two girls stood a little apart form their
parents. Lily seemed to be pleading with her sister; Harry moved closer to
listen.
“...I'm sorry, Tuney,
I'm sorry! Listen -” She caught her sister's hand and held tight to it, even
though Petunia tried to pull away.
What's this? Aunt Petunia actually visited platform nine and
three quarters with Harry's mother? She's been there and knows it exists? So
why is she acting like the idea of a platform called nine and three quarters is
ridiculous twenty or so years later?
My colleague suggests that Aunt Petunia might just be acting
in The Philosopher's Stone, that she remembers platform nine and three quarters
but has trained herself to act like she knows nothing of the magical world,
especially when she's around her husband.
Maybe. But I don't think so. I'd be more ready to believe it
if Rowling described Aunt Petunia as looking down, glancing away, looking
solemn or something like that. But in both cases where Petunia is described in
these passages, she is responding exactly the same way Vernon is: first
staring, then laughing. When Rowling wrote The Philosopher's Stone, she
intended to convey that both Harry's Aunt and Harry's Uncle thought the idea of
a platform nine and three quarters at King's Cross was absolutely ridiculous.
And then forgot that when she came to write The Deathly
Hallows.
I think she knows about the platform but hasn't told Vernon about it. Note that Vernon is the one doing the talking not her. Her laughter could be because Harry doesn't know how to get through the wall.
ReplyDeleteHi Me,
ReplyDeleteI think that's a reasonable explanation but I'm still not sure. Both Vernon and Petunia "stare" when Harry first mentions platform nine and three quarters: I just think the way Rowley wrote that part ("His aunt and uncle stared") is intended to mean they were reacting exactly the same way to what he said: with surprise and shock. But you're right, Petunia doesn't say anything while Vernon does all the talking.
I completely agree with this post. I am also currently re-reading book 1 and just got past that part about Aunt Petunia and Uncle Vernon "staring" at Harry when he mentions the platform number. Her reaction is clearly one of a person who has no idea what the speaker is talking about. I'd like to think that she blocked out everything about Lily's attending Hogwarts but in more than one of the future books she lets things slip that make it clear that she remembers it all quite well. It's likely that she and her parents saw Lily off to Hogwarts more than once. When she joins in with Vernon and Dudley laughing at Harry's being stuck at the station, however, she probably didn't think he'd figure it out in time to catch the train.
ReplyDelete